Considering a new boat, opinions please

[jarobi]

Hello all.

I own a 1974 Lowe Line 1636, decked included a bow casting deck. It doesn't leak a drop and has been great, but my current 6'5" 320-lb. fishing buddy has made stability a real problem. I've decided to buy a new at least 17' hull, set it up the way I want, and keep it forever. I'm mainly a crappie fisherman, but sometimes chase white bass, walleye, and run trotlines. I have a 1981 Johnson 25hp that absolutely refuses to quit. I'll mount it on the new hull until it dies, probably 15 years from now, then I'll attach a 40 horse tiller. Here are the two contenders:

https://www.trackerboats.com/boat/?boat=3269
Tracker 1754 jon
505 lbs.
.100 aluminum, all welded

https://www.loweboats.com/showroom/rivited-jon/lowe-jon/l1852mt.php
Lowe 1854 jon
475 lbs.
.072 aluminum, riveted

These two hulls are within my budget, same price when a livewell is added to the Tracker. Thanks for any input.

 

[bobberboy]

It looks like the Lowe is riveted and not welded. Welded is a good thing if you can afford it. I personally like the Tracker. I have a Tracker 1448 Grizzly and except for the paint job which is average, the boat is great. It's nice to have the center open - the Tracker is designed for that and the floor's already in. I like the configuration of the "U"-shaped bench seat in back and the deck in front. I had a Lowe 1236 before and the Lowe boats are good so I am sure either way you go you'll be happy. With a 54" width you'll be able to take two of your fishing buddies along...

 

[BaitCaster]

The Tracker seems to be the clear choice.

 

[Nevillizer]

I like the tracker for it's wide open floor plan.

 

[KMixson]

The Tracker has a nice floor layout. No ribs to trip over. Lots of room to move about. I would choose the Tracker also.

 

[russ010]

have you looked at any of the Weld Bilt boats? They are all welded, and the price is right in line... They are in Alabama, and the drive is probably worth the price.

https://www.backwoodslanding.com

 

[thudpucker]

Tough choice. Between the two, the Tracker seems best.
Did you shop at AL-Weld?
I have a 1548 from Al-weld that was pretty low cost and is just great for two big guys.

 

[jarobi]

Thanks for the replies! I want at least a 17' hull. That Weldbilt 1752 is right on the money, & their trailers look better and are cheaper than anything Lowe or J. Morris offers. I think I might give them a call. Another thing I like about the WeldBilt is the pedestal seat mount in the center. Something iIwas going to add to the Tracker if I went that route. Thanks again folks!